The Economics of Kindness

Our research, conducted across seven countries and with over six thousand respondents, indicates that kindness plays a role when consumers decide which companies to invest their own money in.

We found that kindness1 was a more powerful determinant of where people would invest their money (chosen by 90.7% of respondents), than the cost of investment (90.5%), the risk (90.1%) or the reputation of the investment manager (87.0%).

90.7% of all consumers saw the responsibility of the firm being invested in as an important factor when deciding which companies to invest their own money in. That number was highest among US consumers (95.3%) and lowest among Netherlands consumers (84.1%). The socially responsible and ethical nature of the investment was flagged as important by 81.2%. Only 3.6% of people thought this factor was not at all important.

1 - via its nearest proxy, “responsible nature of firm”

Picture of Anya Davis

“It’s really encouraging to see that consumers consider how responsible a firm is when deciding whether or not to make an investment. By several counts retail investors hold more than half of the world’s assets under management, so this link between kindness and consumer investment decisions is significant news for managers of any investable firm.
“Companies should embrace this and aim to increase their attractiveness to such investors. Options include taking actions consistent with kindness and ensuring those actions are communicated in all relevant investor communications, such as earnings calls, narrative reports, analyst relations and so on.”
- Anya Davis, partner, expert in energy and resources

What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?

Overall

"What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?" - all regions

 

Reputation of investment manager

87.0%

Responsible nature of firm

90.7%

Cost of investment

90.5%

Potential return

91.4%

Level of risk

90.1%

 

Australia

"What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?" - Australia

 

Reputation of investment manager

88.9%

Responsible nature of firm

92.5%

Cost of investment

94.3%

Potential return

95.1%

Level of risk

93.3%

 

Germany

"What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?" - Germany

Reputation of investment manager

79.5%

Responsible nature of firm

85.6%

Cost of investment

85.0%

Potential return

85.5%

Level of risk

82.6%

 

Netherlands

"What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?" - Netherlands

 

Reputation of investment manager

83.7%

Responsible nature of firm

84.1%

Cost of investment

85.5%

Potential return

89.9%

Level of risk

88.5%

 

Singapore

"What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?" - Singapore

 

Reputation of investment manager

88.2%

Responsible nature of firm

92.0%

Cost of investment

90.2%

Potential return

89.6%

Level of risk

89.8%

 

Switzerland

"What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?" - Switzerland

 

Reputation of investment manager

83.6%

Responsible nature of firm

90.0%

Cost of investment

89.2%

Potential return

89.4%

Level of risk

88.6%

 

United Kingdom

"What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?" - United Kingdom

 

Reputation of investment manager

88.4%

Responsible nature of firm

92.0%

Cost of investment

91.7%

Potential return

92.3%

Level of risk

91.5%

 

United States

"What attributes do you consider most when deciding which companies to invest your own money in?" - United States

 

Reputation of investment manager

93.3%

Responsible nature of firm

95.3%

Cost of investment

94.2%

Potential return

96.0%

Level of risk

94.8%

 

87.0% of all consumers saw the reputation of the investment manager as an important factor when deciding which companies to invest their own money in. That number was highest among US consumers (93.3%) and lowest among German consumers (79.5%). Employees of larger businesses (88.1%) rated this factor as more important than smaller (81.4%).  Trust was rated the most important factor in an investment manager (by 90.4%), with honesty a close second (89.4%).

How important is the socially responsible and ethical nature of the investment?


Responders rating as 'important' by region: 

Overall
Australia
Germany
Netherlands
Singapore
Switzerland
UK
US

81.2%

82.3%

77.1%

71.2%

83.4%

82.4%

80.7%

86.7%

 

How important is the honesty of the investment manager?


Responders rating as 'important' by region

Overall
Australia
Germany
Netherlands
Singapore
Switzerland
UK
US

89.4%

92.0%

85.2%

84.9%

89.5%

88.4%

89.6%

93.4%

 

How important is trust in the investment manager?


Responders rating as 'important' by region:  

Overall
Australia
Germany
Netherlands
Singapore
Switzerland
UK
US

90.4%

91.4%

86.5%

87.3%

90.1%

88.6%

91.5%

95.1%

 

"It’s really encouraging to see how important the responsible nature of the firm is in the consideration of consumers when it comes to personal investment. Once again, it’s clear that kindness in business pays."

Anya Davis, partner, expert in energy and resources

Methodology

The research was conducted by independent market research consultancy, Censuswide. The survey was conducted online with 6,028 employed consumers who have either a pension or some kind of investment in Australia, Germany, Netherlands, Singapore, Switzerland, the UK or the US, between 26.04.2023 - 04.05.2023. Censuswide abide by and employ members of the Market Research Society, which is based on the ESOMAR principles, and are members of the British Polling Council.

Related Insights

Trending content in this series

Kindness makes good business sense.

Kindness equals happy people, which equals better performance, which equals profitability.

Get in touch to find out how we can help your organisation