The agreements made at COP26 at the end of 2021 will directly affect the climate for generations to come – and the future of oil and gas. As demand for fossil fuels drops, oil and gas companies have some difficult choices to make.
In one scenario exercise, Baringa’s analysis suggested that, based on current business models, only a third of Tier 1 oil and gas companies would survive the projected changes to the energy market. So, businesses need to act now to prepare for the bumpy road ahead.
In this series of blogs, we share our insights on how climate change and the response to it will affect the oil and gas industry. And we’ll recommend how companies can analyse their risks, cut their operational emissions, and create low-carbon businesses so they can thrive through the energy transition.
Price drops, lawsuits, and tension with talent: The future of oil and gas
In 2021, for the first time, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has concluded that burning coal, oil, and gas directly causes climate change. They warn that unless emissions are drastically reduced immediately, it’ll be impossible to limit warming to 1.5°C. Deal with a tricky energy transition now, or accept a spiralling climate later. That’s the choice we face.
So where does that leave oil and gas companies? The physical risks from a changing climate are already threatening safe operations – and denting bottom lines. But as governments step up to the IPCC’s words, there are more challenges to come – regulatory, financial, legal, HR.
Regulatory implications: Governments are likely to increase national commitments
To spare the world from the worst impacts of climate change, the goal of the 2015 Paris Agreement was to limit global warming to 1.5°C compared to pre-industrial levels. More than 125 countries committed to peaking of greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, and a climate-neutral world by mid-century.
But current commitments are still leading us on a path to warming of 2.7oC or more by 2100. So, governments are under pressure to increase their national defined contributions (NDCs) at COP27 in Egypt later this year.
Fig. 1: National defined contributions of countries with >1% of global emissions.
To realise their emissions reductions commitments, governments are targeting the power and transportation sectors, responsible for a significant share of emissions. Most of the world’s top countries by GDP have proposed bans on petrol and diesel vehicles. In response, the largest manufacturers have already announced they’ll stop making fossil-fuelled vehicles. On the supply side, 64 governments worldwide have introduced carbon taxes or similar measures aimed at reducing emissions. Regulations designed to steer companies away from fossil fuels are only going to increase.
Financial implications: The cost of capital will rise for companies that aren’t Paris-aligned
The risks from climate change and the financial instability it might lead to are ringing alarm bells in the global financial services sector.
Banks, insurers, and asset managers are starting to measure their counterparties’ credit quality under different 2-degree transition scenarios. In a recent Bank of England scenario analysis exercise, by 2050, oil and gas demand fell by as much as 60% and 75% respectively, and the price of oil fell to $33/boe and of gas to almost zero. Meanwhile, the carbon price rose to $900 per tonne in the UK and EU.
Baringa supported more than half of the 18 participants in this exercise. We concluded that, based on current business models, only 30% of Tier 1 oil and gas companies would weather such drastic changes.
Shareholders are also demanding that banks, insurers, and asset managers set net-zero targets for their lending and investment portfolios, including counterparties’ Scope 3 emissions. Scope 3 includes emissions from customer combustion of sold products, which for oil and gas companies is typically ~90% of their total emissions. Oil and gas companies thus risk falling outside lenders’ and investors’ net-zero commitments and becoming unable to raise the finance they need.
Investors are moving their money into sustainable funds, with 2020 seeing a 96% increase of such investments from 2019. This means the cost of capital, equity, and debt is lower for Paris-aligned companies, and higher for those who are not.
Fig. 2: ESG scores related to cost of capital, equity, and debt
Legal implications: More lawsuits will target oil and gas companies
As societies increasingly take a dim view of producers and consumers of coal, oil, and gas, we expect more litigation against companies not aligned to Paris goals. Over the past two decades, climate lawsuits in 52 countries have tried to change government policy or claim compensation from fossil fuel companies for their contributions to global heating.
Staffing implications: Oil and gas companies may struggle to attract talent
In recent polls in the countries with the highest emissions from the power sector, majorities supported renewable energy and clean vehicles. In a survey of 1,200 young Americans, 62% say a career in oil and gas is unappealing. Two out of three believe the oil and gas industry causes problems rather than solves them. Such unfavourable opinions will make recruitment difficult going forward.
The oil and gas industry is under growing pressure to address climate change issues, with many companies struggling to understand the implications to their business and plan for the future. Join us next time as we explore how oil and gas companies can begin developing their long-term strategies by assessing their climate risks.
For more information contact Johan Nell - email@example.com
Energy Trading Week Insider: navigating the digital energy transition
In this interview, Howard Walker, CEO of America's for Commodities People, talks with Talis Bennett-Verschure, one of Baringa’s Energy and Resources experts about the digital energy transition and its impact on the energy market.Read more
The future of European CfDs
Contracts for Difference have been successful at increasing competition, accelerating capability buildout and stabilising prices in many European states.Read more
New emissions criteria in Australia's National Energy Objectives
In this article we explore implementation challenges and key questions relating to Australia's revised National Energy Objectives.Read more
SAAS Operating Models: empowerment without guardrails is chaos
Key learnings from energy retailers for customer service organisations who are migrating their businesses to new SaaS platforms.Read more